Organic Coconut Oil Labels: What the Wording Means
Pick up a jar that says organic coconut oil and you are holding a small, checkable promise about how the coconuts were grown and handled. That is a good thing to want. It is also only part of what shapes the oil in the jar: how it smells, how fresh it is and whether it is virgin, refined or fractionated are separate questions that the word does not answer. Knowing which is which makes label reading much more fun.
Fractionated Coconut Oil
Our own Fractionated Coconut Oil, in sizes from 0.5 oz to bulk.
From $9.99
Shop Now →A surprise about cosmetics
The agency that regulates cosmetics in the United States does not define the word. FDA's page on organic cosmetics (current as of February 2022) explains that "organic" is not defined in the laws FDA enforces, and that the USDA National Organic Program defines it for agricultural ingredients. A product making an organic claim has to meet USDA's rules for the claim and FDA's rules for labeling and safety. FDA adds a point worth remembering at the shelf: where an ingredient comes from does not determine whether it is safe, and organically grown plants can contain allergenic substances too. Organic describes farming and handling. It is not a promise about how something will feel on your skin.
The three phrases that matter
USDA's rule on product composition, 7 CFR 205.301, sets the tiers, measured by weight or fluid volume with water and salt left out. "100 percent organic" means every ingredient is organically produced. "Organic" means at least 95 percent organically produced agricultural ingredients. "Made with organic" followed by named ingredients means at least 70 percent organic content. Below that, a product can mention organic content only in the limited ways the rule allows.
For a single-ingredient oil, those tiers collapse into a yes or a no. They become interesting in finished products. A lotion that says "made with organic coconut oil" and a bottle of "100 percent organic" oil are making very different promises, and if you are formulating something to sell, the percentages apply to your finished product, so a cream with several conventional ingredients may not reach a tier even when its coconut oil would.
Who stands behind the claim
Certification is the usual route behind an organic label. Under 7 CFR 205.303, the information panel of a packaged product labeled organic names the certifying agent that certified the handler of the finished product, often after a phrase such as "Certified organic by." That name is the most useful thing on the label, because you can follow it up.
There is one more wrinkle, and it is a friendly one. Under 7 CFR 205.101, an operation with gross organic sales of 5,000 dollars or less a year does not need certification, though it must still follow the production, handling and labeling rules and keep records for three years. That gives very small farms and makers a legitimate way to use the word. As a buyer, you can treat "organic" and "certified organic" as two phrases, and if certification matters for your project, ask for the agent's name and a current certificate in writing.
The questions organic leaves open
Here is how we think about it, as reasoning rather than regulation. Organic speaks to the field, and three other choices decide what actually pours out of the bottle.
Virgin, refined or fractionated? The organic rules do not choose among them. An organic virgin oil smells of coconut, and an organic refined or fractionated one is far quieter, which makes them very different oils for a recipe. Our phenolics article covers how the route to the bottle changes what ends up in the oil, and the virgin and refined comparison helps you pick.
Fresh or aged? Oils oxidize with time, heat and light. Freshness shows in lab values such as peroxide value and in a best-by date, rather than in an organic certificate. Our storage article shows how to look after a bottle once it is yours.
Which batch? A certificate applies to a certified operation and its products. If you want to know what a particular batch measured, that is a separate question to put to the seller. It is worth asking before you buy, and a good seller will be glad you did.
Where our oils stand
We do not describe either of our oils as organic, and our pages do not claim organic certification. We sell fractionated coconut oil and a virgin unrefined listing, both neat, for external cosmetic use only. The certificate of analysis we publish covers one fractionated batch and reports appearance, smell, relative density, refractive index and optical rotation. If your product line needs a certified organic ingredient, the right supplier is one who can hand you the certificate and name the certifying agent. If a conventional cosmetic carrier suits you and you want documentation, ask us in writing for what you need before you order, as our bulk buying guide suggests doing with any supplier. You can read how our virgin unrefined listing and our fractionated oil are described on their own pages.
A label routine you can use anywhere
When two bottles sit side by side, read them in this order. Is the claim "100 percent organic," "organic" or "made with organic"? Is a certifying agent named? Does the name say virgin, refined or fractionated, and does the ingredient list agree? Is there a batch number and a best-by date? A label that answers all four tells you far more than the one word on the front. For questions about a claim on your own product, the USDA or a certifying agent is the right place to ask. Once you have read a few labels this way, the shelf stops looking like a wall of identical jars.
Fractionated Coconut Oil
Fractionated Coconut Oil from our own shop, in sizes from 0.5 oz to bulk.
From $9.99
Shop Now →Sources & Further Reading
- US FDA (content current 25 Feb 2022). Organic Cosmetics. fda.gov/cosmetics/cosmetics-labeling-claims/organic-cosmetics
- USDA, 7 CFR 205.301, Product composition. law.cornell.edu/cfr/text/7/205.301
- USDA, 7 CFR 205.303, Packaged products labeled "100 percent organic," "organic," or "made with organic". law.cornell.edu/cfr/text/7/205.303
- USDA, 7 CFR 205.101, Exemptions and exclusions from certification. law.cornell.edu/cfr/text/7/205.101